Metacritic 93
Out of 100
Originally developed as a sequel to Super Mario RPG for the SNES.
Always verify the label print. Original N64 labels have a matte texture. Check for a Nintendo-stamped board inside.
RPG, Adventure · 2001
Paper Mario
Nintendo 64 · Value & Price File
Charming RPG with unique paper-craft aesthetic and turn-based combat with timed button presses.
As of June 2026, loose cartridges typically sell for $75–$90, while complete-in-box copies trade for around $280.
Market valuemarket range · June 2026
Loose~$75–$90CIB~$250–$300
Some links here are eBay affiliate links; a purchase may earn this site a commission.
★ RPG, Adventure · 2001 ★
THE FILE
- Developer
- Intelligent Systems
- Publisher
- Nintendo
- Released
- 2001-02-05
- Genre
- RPG, Adventure
- Players
- 1
- ROM
- 32 MB
- Save
- Flash RAM
- ESRB
- E
- Units Sold
- 1.37M
- Score
- 93 / 100
Collector's Q&A
How much is Paper Mario worth?
As of June 2026, a loose cartridge typically sells for $75–$90. Complete-in-box copies sell for around $280. Live links in the Price Check panel show the latest numbers.
Why does complete-in-box cost more?
The original box and manual were routinely discarded, so surviving complete sets are genuinely scarce. The box and manual can add at least $160 over the loose price.
How do I spot a fake cartridge?
Compare the shell, label, screws, and PCB with documented authentic examples for the same region and board revision. Nintendo markings and security screws are useful clues, but replacement shells and legitimate repairs mean no single detail proves authenticity.
More from the Shelf